What We Know

FDIC Enters Consent Order Regarding Credit Card Add On Products

September 16, 2015 | by Caren D. Enloe

The FDIC has entered into a settlement with Comenity Bank and Comenity Capital Bank regarding their servicing and marketing of credit card add-on products. The liability premise involves Section 5 of the FTC Act, which prohibits unfair and deceptive practices and stems from the banks’ provision through third parties of payment protection/debt cancellation add-on products. As part of the settlement, both banks agreed to pay consumers a total of approximately $61.5 million in restitution, as well as civil money penalties of approximately $2.5 million. As part of the enforcement action leading to the consent order, the FDIC determined that the banks violated the FTC Act by:

  • Representing to consumers that there would be no fee associated with their payment protection/debt cancellation add-on products so long as the account had no balance, but then charging a fee in those circumstances;
  • Making material misrepresentations or omissions as to the refund process for the consumers’ cancellation of the product during the first thirty days of enrollment; and
  • Making material misrepresentations or omissions to consumers regarding the condition of receipt of certain incentives for enrollment.

Beyond the monetary implications, however, the orders contain remediation provisions that should guide other banks, particularly in their management of third party relationships. The Consent Orders require the implementation of an effective third party oversight program, which includes:

  • A review of all aspects of the banks’ agreements with third parties providing services or products to or on behalf of banks;
  • Procedures for effectively monitoring, training, record-keeping, and auditing of banks’ third parties;
  • Access by the banks to all necessary systems of the banks’ third parties to ensure compliance with all consumer protection laws;
  • Monitoring of all third party agreements to ensure they contain specific expectations, obligations, and consequences for compliance with all consumer protection laws;
  • System for maintaining record of all third party agreements and any marketing or solicitation materials developed by the banks’ third parties for add on products;
  • Prompt notification by the banks’ third parties regarding any regulatory inquiries, customer complaints and legal actions received (“other than routine requests such as ‘cease and desist’ collection contact”);
  • Procedures to address and resolve consumer complaints and inquiries regarding services or products provided by third parties; and
  • Procedures to analyze the underlying cause of complaints and identify any complaint patterns or trends regarding specific products or practices.

Financial service companies should carefully review the enforcement actions and the resulting consent orders of this settlement to identify regulatory points of emphasis and prohibited practices, in addition to regulatory guidance on what constitutes an effective compliance management system.

Caren Enloe leads Smith Debnam’ s consumer financial services litigation and compliance group. In her practice, she defends consumer financial service providers and members of the collection industry in state and federal court, as well as in regulatory matters involving a variety of consumer protection laws.  Caren also advises fintech companies, law firms, and collection agencies regarding an array of consumer finance issues. An active writer and speaker, Caren currently serves as chair of the Debt Collection Practices and Bankruptcy subcommittee for the American Bar Association’s Consumer Financial Services Committee. She is also a member of the Defense Bar for the National Creditors Bar Association, the North Carolina State Chair for ACA International’s Member Attorney Program and a member of the Bank Counsel Committee of the North Carolina Bankers Association. Most recently, she was elected to the Governing Committee for the Conference on Consumer Finance Law. In 2018, Caren was named one of the “20 Most Powerful Women in Collections” by Collection Advisor, a national trade publication. Caren oversees a blog titled: Consumer Financial Services Litigation and Compliance dedicated to consumer financial services and has been published in a number of publications including the Journal of Taxation and Regulation of Financial Institutions, California State Bar Business Law News, Banking and Financial Services Policy Report and Carolina Banker.  ...LEARN MORE

Shape919.250.2000 Shapemail@smithdebnamlaw.com noun_20940@smithdebnamlaw